Ukraine Peace Talks Move Toward European Participation as Security Disputes Remain

European representatives are expected to join the next round of negotiations over Russia's war in Ukraine, US envoys said after meetings in Moscow and Dublin. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy welcomed the development, although Reuters reported that Kremlin aide Yury Ushakov did not confirm European participation in his briefing after the Moscow talks.
In an account published early on November 13, >Ukraine's presidential office (opens in a new tab) identified three outcomes from Zelenskyy's meeting with Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner: preparations for a major prisoner exchange, stronger European participation and further multilateral meetings. The exchange remained prospective in that account. Its completion would be a humanitarian result distinct from progress on territorial claims or security guarantees.
That distinction matters because the week has produced movement in who may negotiate and what may be discussed, while leaving the hardest questions open. Adding participants can make commitments more credible, but it also brings the practical question of who can promise what on Europe's behalf.
From Abu Dhabi to Moscow and Dublin
The Ukrainian presidency said negotiations took place in Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11, alongside separate meetings involving European representatives. Witkoff and Kushner then traveled to Moscow before meeting Zelenskyy in Ireland on November 12, a sequence also reported by Reuters.
Kushner said both sides had agreed to expand the next negotiations to include European partners, according to Reuters' November 13 account. He described territorial issues and wider postwar European security as connected subjects, while saying important differences remained. His account also left humanitarian measures able to advance separately from a comprehensive settlement.
This creates two different ways to judge the coming days. A prisoner transfer can be assessed by whether people actually return. A wider negotiating process needs agreed participants, an agenda and eventually commitments that the parties are prepared to implement.
Neither should be used as a substitute for the other. Successful humanitarian cooperation would matter to those released and their families, but it would not establish that the governments had resolved the causes of continuing hostilities.
Why a European seat changes the discussion
Zelenskyy set out the practical argument for European involvement during his November 12 meeting with European Council President António Costa and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. According to the Ukrainian presidency, he said European representatives needed full participation when negotiations concerned European security, European support and obligations Europe would be asked to undertake.
That is more specific than a demand for diplomatic visibility. A security promise has limited meaning unless the governments expected to fund, equip or carry it out are involved in shaping it. Participation also allows those governments to state the limits of their commitments before an agreement is presented as settled.
Irish broadcaster RTÉ reported on November 13 that EU leaders gathering in Dublin would discuss who should represent Europe in substantive negotiations. Its account described overlapping roles for the EU, NATO, the Coalition of the Willing and other formats, illustrating why an invitation alone does not resolve representation.
Ukraine had already been coordinating with several of these partners. Its presidency said Zelenskyy met national security advisers from the United Kingdom, Germany, France and Italy, together with European Commission and European Council officials, on November 12. Their discussion covered recent diplomacy and communication with Washington before the meeting with the American envoys.
The task now is to turn coordination among partners into a workable negotiating presence. A seat at the table does not automatically establish a common position, an agreed mandate or authority to commit resources.
Russia's conditions remain a central obstacle
Reuters reported that Vladimir Putin used the Moscow meeting to restate opposition to Western troops in Ukraine after a peace deal. He also insisted that what Russia considers its state border should be the dividing line, maintaining territorial demands involving Ukrainian regions Moscow claims to have annexed.
Russia launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022, after seizing Crimea in 2014. The distinction between territory a state claims and territory it lawfully possesses remains central to the negotiations; an announcement about talks does not change international recognition of Ukraine's borders.
For Kyiv, the issue is also how any pause could avoid becoming an interval before renewed attack. For Moscow, the publicly stated position ties a settlement to territorial and wider security demands. These are different objectives, and agreeing to discuss them does not mean either side has accepted the other's terms.
The G7 foreign ministers' declaration following their November 9 and 10 meeting supported US-led negotiations and called for a comprehensive, reciprocal ceasefire. It identified a mutual halt to attacks on energy infrastructure and in the Black Sea as an initial step. That was a proposal backed by the ministers, not a ceasefire already operating.
Winter gives the talks an immediate civilian dimension
The diplomatic timetable is unfolding alongside damage to essential services. In a November 9 Security Council briefing, the UN Department of Political and Peacebuilding Affairs said recent Russian attacks on energy facilities had left hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian households without electricity, with outages also disrupting water supplies and public transport.
The same briefing noted reports from Russian authorities of civilian casualties and infrastructure damage from Ukrainian attacks inside Russia. The UN called for attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure to stop wherever they occur.
Earlier evidence explains why temporary repairs alone may be insufficient. In its June report on the previous winter, the UN Human Rights Office described cumulative damage to Ukraine's electricity and heating systems, including prolonged disruptions affecting homes and essential services. It also reported Ukrainian attacks on electricity and heating infrastructure in Russia's Belgorod region.
Zelenskyy's November 12 meeting with Costa and von der Leyen addressed expected energy, humanitarian and shelter assistance, according to his office. Those preparations give the negotiations a parallel track: governments can support civilian needs while diplomats work through terms that may take longer to settle.
What would demonstrate further progress
The clearest near-term indicators are specific. They include confirmation of the next meeting's participants and mandate, implementation of the proposed prisoner exchange, and any agreed reduction in attacks with an identifiable scope and a way to assess compliance.
Security guarantees will require more than a general statement of support. Their meaning depends on the obligations accepted, the circumstances that would trigger action and the governments responsible for responding. Those details are precisely why the question of European participation has become substantive.
For now, the renewed diplomacy has opened a route toward a wider negotiating table. Whether that route produces protection for civilians and a durable settlement will depend on what the parties implement after the meetings, starting with the humanitarian commitments they say can move first.


